Comments on Blog from June to December 2012

11/24/12

Author : namarata gupta

E-mail : namarata21@gmail.com

Comment:

A highly unprofessional approach n proceedings by d investigating team….aarushi’s murder is being considered as a game or a joke…unnocent parents are being thrashed in by d trials….pity on indian law!!!

May aarushi’s soul rest in peace….

=========================================================================

11/20/12

Author : Gayatri Adda

E-mail : Gayatri.adda@gmail.com

Comment:

It must be hard enough for the parents losing their beloved daughter but to be tried for her murder is such  gross injustice.  CBI should understand that the real loss is for the parents and no one else……please leave them alone to cry for their loss and stop the injustice.

===========================================================================

11/12/12

Author : ashok

E-mail : bobynathyal@gmail.com

Comment:

I can’t belive this stupid theory… Investigation teams going on wrong way. We can say “andha kanoon”

We want justice for talwar famly and arushi

==========================================================================

11/12/12

Author : Dr Venkat

E-mail : venki567@hotmail.com

Comment:

It is very pathetic and painful to hear such injustice those who are guilty should be submitted to law

===========================================================================

10/30/12

Author : Himanshu

E-mail : himanshus317@gmail.com

Comment:

God is alwyz their.

Aarushi! U r unforgettable.

We all people are alwys praying for u.

And 1 day justice would be seen.

===============================================================================

10/24/12

From: Harsh Anand <drharshanand@gmail.com>

Subject: i am with Arushi

Message Body:

It is not important just for me rather it is important for every Indian every non-Indian also it is important for every human, especially who are parent …I am a father and I love my family very much ..i do a lot to make my family happy all the time and if any one of my family member suffers from any problem then it hurts me a lot ..i m not able to concentrate on anything…now it’s a matter of loss of a child for their parents…I can understand well how much it is painful for them and on the other hand they are not getting justice for that..it is a shameful thing for our jurisprudence that they are not able to make a justice .

I don’t know about the truth and all facts but YES I know one thing & that is …still Arushi has not got justice …this is a high time for our nation to be awakened..How much we are secure in our own country, you know why..?..look as it is a high profile case and known by almost all…. even though file of this case is still open now think  if something happened to a common man WHAT will happened to them …i’ve seen a lot to media ..media is not a proper way to get a justice but lots of people think like that….media don’t help anybody ..media is just behind the fame, TRP and money that’s it..till media is getting all from your case , will help you but as it stop getting all ..it will stop helping you…

What is the purpose of being educated or a literate person if you are not aware of your country jurisprudence system …you are earning a lot and living happily with your family but THINK the day you have a casualty …what will happen ….??? YES  the same or worsen then this Talwar family…

I am deeply, heartily, and by all means would appeal to my all friends, colleagues, and country people to help them …BE AWARE …

Dr. Harsh Anand

=========================================================================

10/14/12

Author : anuradha chandani

E-mail : smchandani@gmail.com

Comment:

I know they are wonderful people It is impossible for them to kill their own daughter

===========================================================================

8/28/12

From: Munesh <munesh.saharia@gmail.com>

Subject: CBI folks are Assholes

Message Body:

Hi Family,

We really sympathise with you and this great injustice to Rajesh and Nupur.

Pray to God that they are given justice soon and Nupur is released from Jail.

Our family prays for the talwar family. You guys must be going through hell because of CBI.

Most of our friends in US are with the talwar family and be sure that justice willl be served one day.

Thanks

Munesh

Denver USA

==============================================================================

The Mail & Auction Place <mailandauction@yahoo.com>

9/27/12

I have only prayers for the parents what they going through, I don’t know, and don’t want

To know about the daughter, she is gone, why don’t some sensible investigating officer, just close the

Case and let the parents live the remaining life in peace fully, if they can live.

It is just depressing that the case has gone on and on for four years and never ending.

Someone  Please tell the higher up to stop this public drama and close the case, and every tom dick and harry

Stop writing  negative comments, for which they got nothing to do with. It is a sickens me to read every time in news papers the stupid comments.

Daughter is gone, the only child of theirs, whom they loved, who was their heartbeat, let her rest in peace

And lit he parents have the peace.

SHAN

FROM CALIFORNIA U.S.A

==============================================================================

9/18/12

From: Ranjana Mital <ranjanamital@hotmail.com>

Subject: Nupur Talwar’s bail

Message Body:

I was praying for bail to be granted to Nupur  and my prayers like those of many others were granted yesterday.

I am so very relieved for you and your family. I hope this is the beginning of the end of all the humiliation, trauma and suffering you have been subject to.

We in India live in dangerous times and can only hope and pray fervently that this never happens to anybody ever.

with deepest wishes for peace and tranquility to return to your lives.

Ranjana

===============================================================================

9/16/12

Author : dr arun gupta

E-mail : arungupta1959@yahoo.co.in

Comment:

CBI And Ngos are equally resposible for torturing and framing talwars.an Ngo in India will do anything for getting attention and publicity so that they can get grantsand make money and Indian police including cbi were probaly looking for a big B which did not came from talwars side so they framed them

=========================================================================

9/9/12

Author : Sarla sindhu

E-mail : Docsindhu@hotmail.com

Comment:

My heart cries for the injustice done to u,I feel miserable about what u have gone through. It is most unfortunate to see what u  r facing every day without any fault of urs. There is justice in the kingdom of God and he will take care of u. Truth always wins in the end remember it .that day is not far. Very soon the real culprits will be punished and Arushi’ soul will rest in peace .I pray for u always , God is not unkind and he will listen to our prayers very soon . Wish u all the best.

=========================================================================

9/7/12

Author : Himanshu Bose E-mail : hbose13@yahoo.co.in

Comment:

I cannot belief this theory , that Parents can kill their only daughter. Justics will be done to Talwar family. God is great.

==========================================================================

9/7/12

Subject : “Why Didn’t the Talwars Speak Up?”

Author : Manish

E-mail : munesh.saharia@gmail.com

Comment:

Dear CBI,

Why don’t you be professional and bring all facts to the CBI court. Why are you hiding the details about the three servants who should also be tried along with the Talwars when they have accepted to murder both Arushi and Hemraj. Why are you behind the parents who should be given a fair trial. You and UP police have not given them time to mourn the death of their dear one. And Last the COURT has to pronounce them guilty and not the CBI or UP Police or Media.We all want Justice for Aarushi and Hemraj.

===============================================================================

8/28/12

From: ghatotkacha hidimbi bhimasena <ghatotkacha@gmail.com>

Subject: Media as witch-hunters

Message Body:

Dear Talwar family,

I have only the deepest sympathies with you in the ongoing trial – surely the Court will award justice to you; but it is important to ensure that the utterly amoral witch-hunting by the denizens of the media (with all-too-rare exceptions) be highlighted and the guilty exposed before the people.

I take the liberty of pasting a link to a piece I had written a year ago on the matter: I do hope it brings you some comfort and strength.

http://rivr.sulekha.com/rajesh-and-nupur-talwar-guilty-by-sms-poll_503375_blog

Strength to you…justice will prevail!

Regards

Ghatotkacha

=============================================================================

8/29/12

Subject: “Home” http://justiceforaarushitalwar.com

Author : Dipak

E-mail : Dipak_khot@yahoo.com

Comment:

I live in London and have been following this case from day one. I probably must be the only non family member who has extensively read this case and followed it. Most times of India forum I have strongly contested claims about parents being guilty. If convicted I would say CBI has got away with murder. I have so much to say in support and have said in the past on various forums. India is sadly becoming a banana republic with agencies like CBI terrorising the common man. The one thing I understand through my sources is that Krishna is absconding. I think your lawyers should examine him. To my mind he is the real culprit.

============================================================================

8/28/12

Subject: “FATE OF THE TALWARS!”

Author : Poornima E-mail : poornima1234@gmail.com

Comment:

I feel so sorry for the Talwars and so horrified at the apathy of our people. Without even trying to think objectively, everyone is branding them with the gruesome of their own daughter, I can’t even imagine what they must be going through, its like anyone’s worst nightmare. It is so horrifying that people prefer sensationalism over the truth. I can’t imagine anyone with half a brain would even consider the theory of Hemraj-Aarushi affair plausible. I don’t know why people are confusing people from backward societies in some rural village who kill their girl children with modern, educated, kind parents who doted on their daughter. Really, I wish the police and CBI could be sued for even suggesting that rubbish angle.

==============================================================

8/28/12

From: Ankit Kumar <ankit.atish@gmail.com>

Subject: I support

Message Body: Hi, I support the cause, at least her dignity must be restored!

==============================================================================

8/23/12

Subject: “Home” http://justiceforaarushitalwar.com/

Author : niren sachdeva E-mail : niren.sachdeva@gmail.com

Comment: sad , sad , sad all the way….

==============================================================================

8/17/12

Subject: “CBI’s flip-flop on DNA may help Talwars”

Author : R Chandra E-mail : rajaandrani55@yahoo.com

Comment: With the destruction of 90% of the evidence ( wikipedia) this high profile case seems to be doomed from the get go.Whether,  the destruction of evidence was deliberate &amp; carefully thought out or it was just plain stupidity, it means that the judicial system’s hands are tied. There are too many holes in the story of this tragedy. There is almost nothing in the media about Hemraj’s friends &amp; family whose testimony could have proved valuable. The courts have to go on evidence, circumstantial or otherwise in order to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. This fact can also mean that Rajesh &amp; Nupur Talwar will eventually be released. Trial by media &amp; courts of public opinion here have assumed significant proportions &amp; some famous criminal cases that would have gone unpunished but for the intervention of media, such as the Jessica Lal case. However, this case is different, Key witnesses &amp; crucial evidence is missing. In my opinion, for Aarushi &amp; Hemraj, destruction of evidence is justice denied.

===============================================================================

8/10/12

Subject: “IT IS IRONICAL”

Author : Devika

E-mail : devikat@hotmail.com

Comment: Today’s article in Bangalore Mirror, reflects on what a sham our justice system is!

==============================================================================

8/9/12

Subject: “IT IS IRONICAL”

Author : parul mullick

E-mail : parash93@yahoo.com

Comment: Accusing parents without credible evidence is most reprehensible. I hope both Aarushi and her parents get justice long due to them

=============================================================================

8/9/12

From: ajitmansingh ajitmansingh@hotmail.com

Subject: “FATE OF THE TALWARS!”

Message Body: By law, a person is innocent till proved guilty. Here the person is guilty unless proved innocent. Which is absurd. Trial by press and labeling the parents as guilty even before the trial is totally wrong.. irresponsible statements by the police officials on day one itself, blotched up invstigations, and irresponsible reporting and publicity is t be decried.

 

==============================================================================

8/9/12

Subject: “Why Didn’t the Talwars Speak Up?”

Author : K.Mani

E-mail : maniaraja@yahoo.com

Comment:

it is unfortunate that we live in India today with GANG of criminals in all corners involving every government levels and political levels. in Talwar case, it is obvious that CBI could not find the culprit as the culprit cleaverly escaped without leaving any evidence. once CBI surrendered the case as DROPPED, but government felt an INSULT and started re investigation ended with same result as no murderer found. only option is BLAME ON PARENTS who are soft targets so that CBI can escape and government will be pleased . the media is running for their businss only and the public running daily for their bread and do not care even if millions of Aarishis murdered. it is obvious that parents can not kill their only daughter and keep fighting for justice. they lost only child and over and above they have been charged which makes stabbing over wound. it is God’s gift to parents that they have still strength to keep fighting for justice, and I pray for more strength and to get JUSTICE soon. there are chances that even politicians behind covering up the case involved in this murder and as on today anything can happen to anyone as criminals have thousands of loop holes to escape and our system has alreaced the dogs. MAY GOD BRINGS UP THE JUSTICE SOON and my sympathy remains with Talwars and even monitary support for the case if needed.

ohm sai ram

k.mani, chennai

==============================================================================

8/8/12

From: k.mani <maniaraja@yahoo.com>

Subject: aarushi case

Message Body:

CBI has failed misrably and also there must be political influence to cover up . to safe guard CBI from public they have to blame someone as culprit so got the soft target of the parents. the murderer got away cleverly escaped without leaving room to CBI to findout and it is an insult to CBI to surrender as no culprit and unable to trace and charge anyone. media is for their business only and not for justice, and the public do not care what is going on in the country.i am sure GOD will bring out the truth and in the mean time I pray for the strength of Talwars to keep fighting for the truth.

=====================================================================

6/18/12

Subject: The truth behind Aarushi Talwar’s murder

Aiswarya Das <draiswaryadas@yahoo.com>

the whole thing is a mess and one really wonders if ever the truth will see the light.and it is just not justice for aarushi, it also is justice for hemraj because every life is equally valuable.onenear fatal mistake-as parents who also are doctors and are supposed to know the importance of EVIDENCE,the talwars should not have let the police, media ,outsiders trample all over the place and mess around and get rid of evidence in such a haste.now, acquittal/conviction will be based entirely on circumstancial evidence .as a parent,my heart goes out to them.as a doctor, i am kept wondering, and as an Indian i am simply lost

Shreya Talwar justiceforaarushi@gmail.com wrote:

6/19/12

Absolutely. It is justice for Aarushi, Hemraj and her parents. Think for a moment. When you go for surgery, do you tell the doctor what procedure to carry out and how to do it. No. As law abiding citizens, when faced with a tragedy at home, the talwars left the job of investigation to the law enforcement agencies. Each step that was carried out was done after taking the permission of the police. However, the blame for all the mistakes made by the investigating agencies has today been put on the talwars. Imagine the doctor telling you that “you should have told me the steps to follow in the surgical procedure.”  I feel sad that anyone could expect a family that was in severe shock, unable to come to terms with the loss of their only daughter, to give instructions to the police as to how they should investigate the case. In this case, the Talwars have been made scapegoats in the whole process. Now it’s the CBI’s reputation which is at stake. So they have been lying in the courts, changing their version of what they think happened and giving false information to the media.  It is sad to see the premier investigating agency of this country victimizing the parents to prevent the truth regarding the mistakes in their closure report from becoming public. It takes courage and grace to accept a mistake. That grace and courage has yet to be shown by the CBI.

==================================================================================

CBI USES ‘TYPOGRAPHICAL ERROR’ TO SAVE FACE !!

Centre for DNA fingerprinting and Diagnostics (CDFD), Hyderabad’s report of November 2008:

Krishna’s pillow cover has Hemraj’s blood.

December 2010: This fact is missing from the Closure Report filed by CBI.

February 2011: Talwars after being chargesheeted get access to this report and they mention the same in Allahabad High Court.

CBI tells the court that there is a ‘Typographical Error’.

March 2011: CBI seeks a clarification from CDFD on the ‘Typo Error’.

CDFD report on March 24th 2011: An unstamped document says that a‘Typographical Error’ has occurred. 

    2 years after the error had been committed

    1 month after Talwars mention it in court

    1 week after the CBI ‘suggests’ to CDFD about the error.

   1 week after Allahabad High Court judgement accepts the ‘Typo Error’.

Was there really a ‘Typo Error’?

Why then did S.P.R. Prasad, the scientist from CDFD who was cross examined by the defence, say that the CBI had not asked for or received, any of the papers pertaining to how the error was committed in the first place?

Why did Prasad have no idea as to why packages of critical evidence opened before the trial court had no CDFD seals on them?

CDFD claims that findings pertaining to Hemraj’s and Krishna’s bedding were accidentally swapped by some clerk typing the report.

Is that how India’s premier DNA testing lab is supposed to give its reports?

Is the CBI trying to save its face with the ‘Typo Error’?

 

 

GUILTY WITHOUT EVIDENCE – WHERE’S THE JUSTICE ?

Before the enormous tragedy of losing his only child to a gruesome murder had sunk in, Rajesh was arrested. The IG police (Meerut) made many insinuations about the family members and the servant.

THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE.

1st CBI team took over and Rajesh was released based on various investigations.

A year later, 2nd CBI team took over, and later filed for closure.

Closure report was full of insinuations against the parents.

THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE.

Nupur was arrested in April 2012 by CBI.

THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE AGAINST HER.

Trial started in June 2012.

THERE IS STILL NO EVIDENCE.

Media has played to the gallery and public has declared Rajesh and Nupur guilty

WITHOUT ANY EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER.

WHERE’S THE JUSTICE ???

RAJESH AND NUPUR HAD NO REASON TO KILL THEIR DAUGHTER, AARUSHI !

Rajesh and Nupur were a well settled dentist couple from a decent family background and good social standing.

Aarushi was their only child, conceived after 5 yrs of marriage.

Aarushi was to celebrate her 14 th B’day just 2 days later. Her parents had bought a camera and gifted it to her on 15th night, a couple of hrs before the murder. Her friends were expected to come on 17th night for a sleep over and the party was arranged for the 18th.

Theirs was a happy, loving family with no discord. How come the salacious gossip about a relationship between a 13 yr old girl and a grand fatherly servant is known only to the investigating teams and sections of the media ? Would somebody from school, family, friends or neighbors not have said something in these 4 and a half years, if there was anything amiss in the family relationships?

Aarushi was only 13 years old. Would her parents not have counseled her even if they had suspected something?

Aarushi was their life.

How could they have killed a part of themselves, that too without any reason!

 

 

 

Report on the Statements of key witnesses produced by CBI to implicate the Talwars – Compiled by SHIBA Mehra and AMIT HARSH

Witness 1 : Chunni Lal, a Noida Police Staff

Witness 2 : Dr Sunil Dohre, who did autopsy on Aarushi’s corpse.

Witness 3 : B P Mohapatra, an expert in Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL).

Witness 4 : KK Gautam, a retired UP police officer.

Witness 5 : Shohrat, a painter.

Witness 6 : Sanjay Chauhan, a morning walker.

Witness 7 : Bharti, maid servant of Talwars :

Witness 8 : Kripa Shankar Tripathi is a pandit in the Noida Crematorium :

Witness 9 : Dr Rajeev Varshney and Dr Rohit Kochar, friends of Talwars :

Witness10 : Puneesh Tandon, neighbour :

Witness 11 : Umesh Sharma, who is Talwar’s driver

Witness 12 : Laxman Singh, DDA staff :

Witness 13 : Virendar Singh, Security Guard, Jalvayu Vihar Complex :

Witness 14 : Kalpana Mandal, Another Domestic Help, Maid Servant of Talwars :

 

Witness 1 : Chunni Lal, a Noida Police Staff :

Chunni Lal of NOIDA police staff, who took the photographs of the crime scene / site and collected fingerprints, responded in the Court against most of the questions put before him in cross-examination that .. “dhyaan nahin hai” i.e. “Not able to recollect” …

It not out of place to mention that almost two years after the murders he adds on a statement to the second team of CBI on 29 March, 2010 that ..

* The whiskey bottle on table had blood stains,
* A stuffed toy on Aarushi’s bed without blood on it, and
* The pyjamas of Aarushi lying low around her waist with the string open.

Strangely, there was a significant mismatch between positives the photos produced by CBI in Court and the negatives of the photos took by Chunni Lal.

Interestingly Chunni Lal on the morning of 16th May, 2008, just after few hours of Crime, took only 5 photographs, while CBI produced 8 photographs.

Moreover, 22 fingerprints were smudged, out of 24 fingerprints took by Chunni Lal.

* * * * * *

Witness 2 : Dr Sunil Dohre, who did autopsy on Aarushi’s corpse :

Dr Sunil Dohre, who did postmortem on Aarushi’s body remembered new aspects about the condition of her body a few years later.

A look at his changing versions as under :

# 16 May, 2008 : Dr Dohre wrote in his autopsy report that

* Murder happened to be mid-night (12.00pm to 1.00am) of 15 to 16 May, 2008
* Cause of Death : Shock due to ‘Hypovolemia’, which means blood loss
* Genital : NAD ( Nothing Abnormality detected)

Note : This report denied any sexual assault etc. .
Moreover, Sharp Weapon is used to slit the wind pipe of neck etc. was also missing from PM.

# Sept., 2008 : Dr Dohre told to AIIMS experts that murder-weapon could be a ‘khukri’.

# 30 Sept., 2009 : Dr Dohre, suddenly remember changed his version that

* The vaginal opening was found prominently wide open and
* The hymen was ruptured

# 28 May, 2010 : Further, Dr Dohre remembers some more details that

* The vaginal secretions being unevenly spread, thus implying cleaning of vaginal canal
* The murders were committed by a surgically trained person.
* The head injury could have been caused by a golf club.

* * * * * *

Witness 3 : B P Mohapatra, an expert in Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL):

B P Mohapatra, an expert in Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL) told to the Court that he is not able to recollect that the pillow carrying DNA of Hemraj, collected from which room.

The CBI had told the Court months ago that the said pillow cover was collected in Hemraj’s room.

However, CBI was later trying to imply in the Court that it was retrieved from Aarushi’s room in an attempt to corroborate the perverted theory of Aarushi and Hemraj’ affair.

The tag on the pillow case, later was read out aloud in Court that said that it was indeed recovered from Hemraj’s room.

Interestingly, Mohapatra also did not follow the rules laid down by the ‘National Accreditation Board of Testing and Calibration Laboratories’ (NABL) while taking pictures of the articles collected for performing tests.

* * * * * *

Witness 4 : KK Gautam, a retired UP Police Officer :

KK Gautam, a retired UP Police Officer who was instrumental in discovering Hemraj’s body, made erratic statements and inconsistent at different point of time. An overview of his statements, as under :

# Statement made to ‘First Team of CBI’ that he noticed

* The depressions on Hemraj’s bed that suggested three people may have sat on it.
* There were three glasses on the floor, and

* The servant’s bathroom was dirty, as if several people had used it and hadn’t flushed.

# Two years later, he told to ‘Second Team of CBI’ that his doctor friend, Sushil Chaudhari, had called him and asked if he could use his influence to get the word ‘rape’ left out of the post-mortem report to which he refused to oblige.

Here, CBI is trying to prove by the deliberate statement of KK Gautam that ‘Talwars’ were trying to influence Autopsy Report.

# In Court, KK Gautam made some statements to the effect that the ‘First Team of CBI’ tried to implicate, incriminate him the matter so he didn’t tell some important aspects related to the case and most of the statements ‘First Team of CBI’ had registered are not made by him.

It is interesting that KK Gautam has duly signed on the statement sheet, which he made to ‘First Team of CBI’.

* * * * * *

Witness 5 : Shohrat, a painter :

Shohrat, a painter, told to the Court that he painted the flat i.e. crime-site in December, 2009, i.e. almost after 18 months of the crime.

Moreover, it is pertinent to mention that the painting / white wash of the flat was done with due permission and knowledge of CBI.

It is really childish, silly and inappropriate claim of CBI that painting of flat was done with a mala-fide intention to destroy evidences.

* * * * * *

Witness 6 : Sanjay Chauhan, a morning walker :

Sanjay Chauhan, a morning walker, stated in Court that despite the atmosphere was full of grief Aarushi’s father showed inadequate signs of grief, when saw him on 16th May morning at site of crime.

It is not out of place to mention that the residence of Sanjay Chauhan is around 56 km far from the crime site, and he commuted 56 kms to just for ‘morning walk’ at Jal-Vaayu Vihar Complex.

Interestingly, no one seems to have a recollection of meeting Sanjay Chauhan on the said day.

* * * * * *

Witness 7 : Bharti, maid servant of Talwars :

Bharti, a maid servant of Talwars, who was the first to arrive at their home on 16 May Morning, told to the Court that the entrance door was locked from inside. Meanwhile, she divulged to the Court that she is making the statement as per the direction of CBI.

By her statement CBI wants to prove that there was no entry or exit of outsider in the flat, during the night of murder.

It is pertinent to mention that here in many occasion Bharti told that the door was latched from outside.

* * * * * *

Witness 8 : Kripa Shankar Tripathi is a pandit in the NOIDA crematorium :

Kripa Shankar Tripathi is a pandit in the NOIDA crematorium, says the Talwar family performed the funeral on 16th afternoon, took a locker to keep Aarushi’s remains / ashes, and came back on the 17th morning to pick ashes.

It is needless to mention that the cremation of the Aarushi’s Body was performed in knowledge and permission of police.

CBI’s claim that Talwars’ were in hurry to dispose the ashes, seems silly and uncalled-for.

* * * * * *

Witness 9 : Dr Rajiv Varshney and Dr Rohit Kochar, Friends of Talwars :

Dr Rajiv Varshney and Dr Rohit Kochar, the first to inspect the stains on the lock, door and stairs to the terrace had informed and brought in notice to the police to pursue the evidence, but no action, cognizance or due diligence actuated by Noida Police.

They further, testified that no key of terrace door lock was enquired or asked from Talwars, neither by them nor police in their presence. Furthermore, they confirm that in their statements that no blood stain was on the clothes of Dr. Talwar Couple.

It should be noted that CBI had claimed the there were blood stains on Dr Talwar’s clothes and he avoided and circumvented to provided key of lock at terrace door, even it was asked by them repeatedly.

Moreover, they confirmed to the Court that Dr Rajesh Talwar was weeping uncontrollably on the day of the murders.

* * * * * *

Witness 10 : Puneesh Tandon, Neighbor:

Punish Rai Tandon who lived a floor below the Talwars, deposed in the court that there were blood stains on the steps leading down from his flat.

What Punish Tandon told the court challenged a basic premise of the CBI’s case, if a blood trail led down from the Talwars’ flat, how could the possibility of intruders be ruled out?

He also said that he went to the Talwars’ flat in the morning as he heard loud wailing coming from there.

* * * * * *

Witness 11 : Umesh Sharma, who is Talwar’s driver

Prosecution witness Umesh Sharma, who is Talwar’s driver was declared hostile by CBI, because he admitted in the Court that CBI had tortured him and he is still working with Talwars.

He admitted in Court that he had received an ear drum splitting and slap by the CBI officer.

He told to the Court that Dr. Rajesh Talwar & Dr. Nupur Talwar were in same clothes as seen in last night and there was no blood stain on them. He did not identify golf-stick handed over to CBI by Dr. Rajesh Talwar.

* * * * * *

Witness 12 : Laxman Singh, DDA staff :

Laxman Singh, DDA clerk, testifies that he was present at the CBI office on 2 August, 2010 when Umesh, the Talwars’ driver, pulled out two clubs from a golf bag and identified them as the ones he had transferred from Dr Talwar’s car to Hemraj’s room before the murders.

Interestingly, But the hood of the bag, which carries those Golf Clubs, still bears a 2009 CFSL seal.

So either Laxman Singh is lying or the seals placed on crucial evidence (golf bag) had been broken or tampered with.

Amusingly, also the memo signed by the Umesh, driver is in English, which he said he cannot read.

* * * * * *

Witness 13 : Virendar Singh, Security Guard, Jalvayu Vihar Complex :

Testimony of Virendar Singh, Security Guard, Jalvayu Vihar Complex establishes that there were several ways of getting in and out of the complex without encountering him at the main gate.

Moreover, if the assailant lived in Jalvayu Vihar complex – as the one-time suspect Krishna did, he didn’t need to pass any guards on duty that night at all.

* * * * * *

Witness 14 : Kalpana Mandal, Another Domestic Help, Maid Servant of Talwars :

Talwars’ maid Kalpana Mandal, who was on leave during the murders, was to be produced as witness in Court, but couldn’t be produced.

Since she is still working for Talwars’ family therefore, CBI claimed she would have been influenced by the Talwars.

Note : This Report is based on Media Reports & the information shared by reliable sources associated with the case.

 

 

 

Didn’t mention Dinesh Talwar’s name to CBI: Vodafone official – Indian Express, Oct 31st’2012

The cross-examination of CBI witness Deepak Tomar, nodal officer for Vodafone, was conducted by the defence counsel in the Aarushi-Hemraj murder case on Tuesday.

Tomar told the court that he had never mentioned Dr Dinesh Talwar to CBI investigators and did not know how the name appeared in his statement. Dinesh is Rajesh Talwar’s brother.

Dentist couple Rajesh and Nupur Talwar are the accused in the double murder case. In court, Tomar said his company was asked for the call records of three phone numbers on July 7, 2008.

CBI officials had said the importance of this witness was to prove a chain of calls between Dr Sushil Chaudhary, ex-Noida police officer K K Gautam and Dinesh Talwar.

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/didn-t-mention-dinesh-talwar-s-name-to-cbi-vodafone-official/1024241/0

Earlier, in his statement to court, Gautam had said Dr Sushil Chaudhary had asked him to remove any mention of rape from Aarushi’s post-mortem report.

Tomar told court, “It is wrong to say I mentioned K K Gautam’s name at the insistence of the CBI. I do not know Dr Dinesh Talwar’s phone number and I have not seen his call records. I had not mentioned his name to the investigators and I do not know why it is mentioned.”

The defence asked Tomar if Vodafone had received the customer application forms for the numbers, whose call details were sought by the CBI. In response, Tomar said, “I do not remember if I saw the corresponding customer application forms and whether they were given to the CBI.”

Defence counsel Tanveer Ahmed Mir said, “According to law, ownership of the mobile phones cannot be ascertained without placing their customer application forms on record.”

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/didn-t-mention-dinesh-talwar-s-name-to-cbi-vodafone-official/1024241/0

 

 

“HAMARI AARUSHI” A BEAUTIFUL POEM BY AMIT HARSH : ! : ! : ! : हमारी आरुषी : ! : ! : ! : ! : !

हादसे थे …. कि हद से पार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 कुसूर इतना … कि सच कह दिया

जो कुछ था पता … सब कह दिया

गलती बस इतनी … कि गलत नहीं किया

किसी पर भी … हमने शक नहीं किया

अंजाम हुआ कि शक के दायरे में आ गए

…अनकहे बयान हमारे .. चर्चे में आ गए

तर्क--दलीलसारे तार तार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 पीड़ा पीड़ित की जाना ही नहीं कोई

टूटा है पहाड़ हमपे .. माना ही नहीं कोई

हँसती खिलखिलाती मासूम बेटी गंवा दी

हमने सारे जीवन की पूँजी गंवा दी

इल्ज़ाम ये है कि कुछ छुपा रहे है हम

क्या बचा है अब .. जो बचा रहे है हम

 पल पल जिंदगी के …. उधार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 उम्मीद थी कि दुनिया ढाढस बंधाएगी

उबरने के इस गम के तरीके सुझायेगी

पर लोगो ने तो क्या क्या दास्ताँ गढ़ ली

जो लिखी न जाए, .. ऐसी कहानी पढ़ ली

मीडिया ने हमारे नाम की सुर्खिया चढ़ा ली

चैनलों ने भी लगे हाथ …. टीआरपी बढ़ा ली

 अंदाज--अटकलों से रंगे अखबार हो गए

और हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 हँसती खेलती सी एक दुनिया थी हमारी

हम दो ….. और एक गुड़िया थी हमारी

दु:खों को खुशियों की खबर लग गई

जाने किस की नज़र लग गई

कुसूर ये जरूर कि हम जान नहीं पाए

शैतान हमारे बीच था, पहचान नहीं पाए

बगल कमरे में छटपटाती रही होगी

बचाने को लिए हमें बुलाती रही होगी

जाने किस नींद की आगोश में थे हम

खुली आँख … फिर न होश में थे हम

ये ‘गुनाह’ हमारा ‘काबिल-ए-रहम’ नहीं है

पर मुनासिब नहीं कहना कि … हमें गम नहीं है

 खुद नज़र में अपनी .. शर्मसार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 पुलिस, मीडिया, अदालत से कोई गिला नहीं है

वो क्या कर रहे है …… खुद उन्हें पता नहीं है

फजीहत से बचने को सबने .. फ़साने गढ़ दिए

इल्ज़ाम खुद की नाकामी के .. सर हमारे मढ़ दिए

‘अच्छा’ किसी को … किसी को ‘बुरा’ बनाया गया

न मिला कोई तो हमें बलि का बकरा बनाया गया

असलीयत बेरहमी से मसल दी जाने लगी

फिर .. शक को सबूत की शकल दी जाने लगी

 तथ्य’, .. ‘सत्यसारे निराधार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 सेक्स, वासना, भोग से क्यों उबर नहीं पाते

सीधी सरल बात क्यों हम कर नहीं पाते

बात अभी की नहीं … हम अरसे से देखते है

हर घटना क्यों … इसी चश्मे से देखते है

ईर्ष्या, हवस, बदले से भी ये काम हो सकते है

क़त्ल के लिए पहलू .. तमाम हो सकते है

जो मर गया उसे भी बख्शा नहीं गया

नज़र से अबतलक वो नक्शा नहीं गया

उम्र, रिश्ते, जज़्बात का लिहाज़ भी नहीं किया

कमाल ये कि .. किसी ने एतराज़ भी नहीं किया

कितने विकृत विषमय विचार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

 इन घिनौने इल्जामों को झुठलाना ही होगा

सच मामले का … सामने लाना ही होगा

वरना संतुलन समाज का बिगड़ जाएगा

बच्चा घर में .. माँ बाप से डर जाएगा

कैसे कोई बेटी …. माँ के आँचल में सिमटेगी

पिता से कैसे .. खिलौनों की खातिर मचलेगी

गर .. साबित हुआ इल्ज़ाम तो हर बच्चा सहम जाएगा

रिश्तों का टूट … हर तिलस्म जाएगा

 बेमाने सारे रिश्ते नाते .. परिवार हो गए

हम अपने ही क़त्ल के गुनाहगार हो गए

~ ~ { …. “तलवार दम्पतिके दर्द को समर्पित …. } ~ ~

Amazing how deeply this writer can feel

Nupur and Rajesh’s pain

when he is not even remotely related to them or has ever met them

A Beautiful Poem

  By

AMIT HARSH

GOD FORBID THIS HAPPENS TO ANY OF US!

God forbid there’s a tragedy in the family!

God forbid that it happens in the dead of the night when you are sleeping in the adjoining room.

God forbid that when you get up in the morning, your most precious one, the reason for your very existence is found brutally murdered.

God forbid that the needle of suspicion falls on you!

But why should that happen, you ask.

Because you were sleeping in the house when that happened, and you are liable to give the answers!

Do you really think it can’t happen to you? How many of us have live-in servants who are as likely to open the door to friends as you are, any time of the day or night?

Do you think the police can’t arrest you?

Did you know that you don’t really need to do a crime to be framed?

The fact is that many of the people languishing in jail are innocent.

Do you think the system won’t be against you someday, if it has to save its own prestige?

You don’t know how lucky you are if you’ve not had to face such trying circumstances!

Dr. Rajesh and Dr. Nupur Talwar are the victims of such a circumstance, that too after losing their beloved daughter in a most gruesome manner.

They have been falsely accused and are being framed. The entire system is against them because the almighty CBI has decided whatever it proclaims is the ultimate truth and evidence be damned! And if you dare to show that there are glaring mistakes in their story, they are allowed to concoct a new story.

After all, who can challenge the might of the CBI!

 

IS THE CBI FRAMING THE TALWARS?

I

Both Rajesh and Nupur have been subjected to about 9 scientific tests each to prove or disprove their innocence.

In June 2008 Rajesh and Nupur underwent POLYGRAPH and PSYCHO-ANALYSIS tests

In July 2008 the then CBI Joint Director, Mr. Arun Kumar announced that there was

NO DECEPTION in the polygraph tests, and their psycho-analysis tests show the possibility that they are

NOT INVOLVED IN THE CRIME. (The Tribune online edition, July 11, 2008, N. Delhi)

In 2010 after the 2nd CBI team took over, they were again asked to undergo scientific tests.

They underwent narcoanalysis, and  the polygraph tests and brain mapping were again repeated.

Conclusion of the narcoanalysis report dated 02/2010  by the Directorate of Forensic Sciences, Gandhi Nagar:

“Dr Rajesh Talwar and Dr Nupur Talwar do not indicate their participation related to the crime and the sequence in which the crime has taken place in their premises. Neither the information indicated their awareness about the twin murder of Aarushi and Hemraj”

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcQuNhUM-vE&feature=plcp

On the other hand let’s have a look at the Servants Tests:

June 2008: Krishna underwent the lie detector test at CFSL, and psychological assessment at AIIMS and failed these tests.

He then underwent another polygraph and narco at Forensic Science Laboratory (Bangalore).

The then CBI Joint Director, Mr. Arun Kumar said that Krishna confessed to the crime in the narco.

June 2008: Rajkumar and Vijay Mandal were subjected to polygraph test at CFSL, and a

repeat polygragh, psychological assessment, brain mapping and narco at FSL, Bangalore.

Mr Arun Kumar said that the narco tests clearly showed the servants guilty and arrested them.

             http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ghy-oX3h-a0&feature=plcp

Despite this the 2nd CBI team seems to have

worked with a one-purpose agenda

WHAT?

To make insinuations against the Talwars without any evidence.

The CBI itself says that though these tests are not conclusive, they are indicative.

The agency relies upon it as a point of reference to make sure they are on

the right track to getting to the accused.

Why then did they not follow that track?

Even in their own closure report they wrote that the servants are clear except for the narco. 

As per record given in the closure report, the servants were not subjected to any investigation or tests

despite their having had a clear involvement in the 1st round of tests.

WHY DID THE CBI DO THIS????

 

 

THE AARUSHI TALWAR CASE DIARY – Part 2

VICTIMS MADE ACCUSED BY THE CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Even though the Central Bureau of Investigation filed for closure of the Aarushi Talwar case, the Ghaziabad trial court magistrate decided to summon both Rajesh and Nupur, despite the fact that Nupur’s name was not even mentioned in the closure report.

Central Bureau of Investigation

Though the Talwars opposed the summoning order in the High Court and Supreme Court, the courts did not interfere on the grounds that the Magistrate was within her right to summon any one. Unfortunately, the courts declined to go into the reports showing that the CBI was suppressing and manipulating forensic evidence, and asked the trial court to look into the evidence. 

Nupur was arrested on 30th April 2012 and was lodged in Dasna Jail, Ghaziabad. She has been given bail by Supreme Court on 25th September 2012. Both Rajesh and Nupur cooperated fully during the investigations and had full faith in the Central Bureau of Investigation and had thought that as the national investigation agency, the CBI would pursue a course of action against the suspects as was revealed during the investigation. They did not realize that this organization is infiltrated by criminal elements who are misusing their official position to fabricate evidence with impunity and have no qualms in switching and swapping samples in utter violation of prescribed procedures to frame innocent persons.
Malafide intent of the 2nd team of Central Bureau of Investigation is revealed from their own reports as they constantly keep changing the facts to maintain that Talwars are the suspects:

  1. Scientific tests carried out on the Talwars are clear, whereas that of the servants show their involvement in the crime. If these tests are not admissible in court, why did the CBI do approximately 9 tests each on Rajesh and Nupur? CBI itself states that the tests are indicative and give some direction as to which lead to follow. Why then did the 2nd team of CBI not investigate the servants and in fact gave them a clean chit whereas the 1st team of CBI had actually arrested them based on the same scientific tests. IF THE CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION HAD NOTHING TO HIDE WHY DID THEY NOT SUBMIT THESE TESTS TO THE MAGISTRATE HANDLING THE AARUSHI TALWAR CASE IN THE TRIAL COURT?
  2. Krishna’s pillow cover has one of the victim – Hemraj’s blood on it. This DNA report was forwarded by the Director CDFD, to the Director CFSL on 6.11.2008. However, the report was not acted upon by either the CFSL or the CBI investigators. The fact that Krishna’s pillow cover has Hemraj’s blood on it was mentioned by the defendant in the Allahabad High court on 28th February 2011. As an afterthought, the Central Bureau of Investigation wrote to the CDFD on 17th March 2011 asking for a clarification. It was only on 24th March 2011 that a letter from a Scientist Incharge at CDFD came stating there was a typographical error and the pillow cover actually belonged to Hemraj. There is no stamp on that report unlike the previous reports from CDFD which have a stamp on all the papers.
  3. Khukhri’ recovered from Krishna’s room which has blood stains on it was never sent to CDFD Hyderabad for DNA testing.
  4. The PM (post mortem) report of Aarushi Talwar says that vagina was NAD (no abnormality detected). But one and a half years later the PM doctor (Dr. Sunil Dohare) changed his statements to the 2nd team of CBI and stated that the vagina was dilated, hymen had an old tear and secretions were present in the base of vagina and mouth of cervix (and according to the Central Bureau of Investigation this implies cleaning of the vaginal canal). If these findings were so relevant, why are they not mentioned in the PM report and why did the PM doctor not mention it to the expert committee constituted in AIIMS in 2008 of which he was a member and had signed each page of that report.
  5. The same expert committee concluded that Hemraj was possibly killed on the terrace. No blood of Hemraj was found in Aarushi Talwar’s’s room even according to the closure report. Both Rajesh and Nupur did not have Hemraj’s blood on their clothes on the morning of the murder. The fact that they wore the same clothes on 15th night and 16th morning was confirmed by the CBI closure report itself.
  6. The same expert committee, of which Dr. Sunil Dohare and Dr.Naresh Raj (Doctor who conducted Hemraj’s PM) were members had said that the murder may have been caused by a ‘khukhri’. However, at the time the closure report was filed, the statement of Dr. Sunil Dohare and Dr. Naresh Raj was twisted to say that the weapon of offence was a golf club and scalpel. Who is more reliable as a witness? The expert committee or the statement of 2 doctors whose version changes with the changing team of Central Bureau of Investigation?
  7. The 2nd CBI team suddenly came up with the golf club (No. 5 iron being the murder weapon) theory one and a half years after the murder. They claim that golf club No. 5 is the murder weapon, not because it has blood on it, but because it is cleaner than the rest (meaning thereby that the parents cleaned the weapon after using it). But their own report shows that iron golf club No. 5 has not been cleaned. When the Central Bureau of Investigation team realized this, they changed their stance after the framing of charges and said that actually golf club No. 4 was the murder weapon!

Central Bureau of Investigation 2

It is very unfortunate that Rajesh and Nupur are undergoing the trial for murdering their lovely daughter Aarushi Talwar, whom they doted upon and who was the very reason for their existence. Instead of giving justice to the grieving parents by finding the killers of Aarushi, the National Investigation Agency labeled them the killers even before the trial began. As parents, to survive after the loss of your only child to a gruesome murder is bad enough, but to be made scapegoats and be continuously and deliberately labeled as the killers of your own child to preserve the prestige of the CBI is not only inhuman but barbaric. Can there be more injustice than undergoing the trial in the glare of this extremely negative public perception created by both the Central Bureau of Investigation and the media.

The acts committed by the national investigation agencies which are supposed to uphold the law but are actively engaged in manipulating evidence to frame innocent people are unsurpassed in their heinousness. They have no morality or scruples whatsoever and are willing to go to any length for their self serving objectives without even a twinge of conscience. The Talwars have been hounded like criminals, humiliated, and characters of Rajesh, Nupur, Aarushi and Hemraj have been assassinated at the instigation of some unscrupulous elements of the CBI on the national media continuously and deliberately over the last 4 years.

The law enforcers as well as the media have effectively destroyed the concept of the Indian family and values of our society. If the corrupt and self serving police and their criminal nexus is going to turn the cases on the victims themselves then no citizen is safe in this country! 

We appeal to everyone to please look in an unbiased manner into the various facts on the case and not blindly believe whatever is said by the CBI.  It is important to take a stand to fight for the truth if we have to ensure that justice is done. For preserving their own prestige it may not matter to the CBI who is made a scapegoat, but the message which will go to the rest of the nation will be shameful for each and every citizen. No daughter will henceforth feel safe in her own home. In addition, this will ensure that the Central Bureau of Investigation actually perpetrates crime by letting criminals walk free to create yet another Aarushi Talwar!

Read more:

Central Bureau of Investigation

http://www.firstpost.com/delhi/is-the-final-cbi-case-on-aarushi-too-reliant-on-speculation-186098.html

http://www.firstpost.com/breaking-views/why-did-cbi-discard-crucial-evidence-in-aarushi-case-184640.html